The Greek deficit crisis could turn into a Lehman-type event capable of freezing the financial markets, according to a report today from Deutsche Bank.
If Greece acts to restructure its debt at the expense of current bond holders, it could cause financial markets to freeze up just as they did after the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy in September 2008. Despite trillions in economic stimulus and bailout cash from the world’s governments some markets for some types of assets still aren’t functioning.
It’s good these days to read any warning of danger in the financial markets with a pound of salt. Someone may be yelling, The sky is falling because they want to get regulators to back off on proposals for stricter regulation or because they’re still looking for a government handout.
So how good is Deutsche Bank’s argument?
I think the report makes a plausible case that a restructuring of Greek debt would set some dominoes in motion. If as part of some plan that would reduce the country’s need for near-term funding, Greece forces its bond investors to take a haircut on the price of their bonds in any restructuring or suspends interest payments in the run up to a restructuring, bond investors who hold sovereign debt from other high-deficit countries could decide to sell those holdings or to demand higher yields. That would make it more expensive for countries such as Portugal and Spain to sell new debt in the financial markets to fund big current deficits and to refinance maturing debt. Forcing these countries to pay more interest on their debt would, in turn increase fears that these countries, like Greece, would be forced to restructure their debt at the expense of bond holders. That increased worry would push interest rates higher, leading to increased worry over restructuring. And on and on.
At its worst, this cycle ends with a country—Greece, Portugal, Spain, or whatever—unable to roll over its debt or to fund the current deficit. The banking system in that country could freeze since banks with big portfolios of sovereign debt wouldn’t be able to either sell it or borrow on it from the European Central Bank. That would cause parts of the national banking system to go into crisis.
All that’s true and it would have tremendous negative consequences for the countries involved and the European Union as a whole. The crisis could spread to the United Kingdom and to banking systems, such as that of Germany, with big exposure to the sovereign debt of these countries.
But it’s hard for me to see this setting off something like the post-Lehman global financial crisis—because the banks at risk in such a crisis don’t have the kinds of leveraged interconnections with the global banking system that a Lehman, an American International Group (AIG), or a Citigroup (C) did in the run up to that crisis. Lehman’s bankruptcy rippled out across the global financial system because that investment bank was the counter-party in so many leveraged deals. As counter-party Lehman had taken on or laid off some part of the risk in a deal that involved other financial institutions. When Lehman failed, those other financial institutions were left holding a deal without anybody on the other end. If, for example, a risky deal where Lehman had bought some of the risk from other institutions (for a price, of course) went bad those institutions had no one to collect from. And since they had themselves signed deals with other institutions over that same risk, when Lehman wasn’t around to pay up, those institutions couldn’t meet their obligations either. And since no one knew what banks owned what parts of what risk—absent Lehman—the markets for those assets froze since no one could accurately price anything.
In any post Greece crisis, the chain of risk would be much shorter. It would include the banks that bought the sovereign debt of Greece, Portugal, Spain, or whatever, the national central bank and the European Central Bank that made loans to these banks with that sovereign debt as collateral, and whatever investment banks or other financial institutions that insured the risk in the derivatives markets. That last class of institutions worries me because I don’t know who stands on the other side of the insurance policies against default that bond investors are buying at ever higher prices in the credit default swaps derivative market.
Still the amounts involved and the likely holding patterns make it hard to see how this turns into the kind of crisis that freezes borrowing in the commercial paper market, for example. The commercial paper market that ceased to function in the post-Lehman crisis was about $2.2 trillion. Greece’s entire GDP is just $341 billion. Spain’s is $1.37 trillion.
That’s not to say that the renewed worry over Greece and the possibility that it might spill over to Portugal, Spain, and the United Kingdom isn’t a real worry. The crisis has exposed the weakness at the center of the European Union. There is no formal mechanism for dealing with a crisis like this and so far very little leadership from the squabbling national governments that are the only feasible source of a response to the crisis.
Imagine if in the days after Lehman, instead of the U.S. government taking strong action to prevent the crisis from taking down American International Group, Citigroup, and other big banks, investors had witnessed weeks of indecision as Maryland fought with Montana and Georgia over what if anything to do.
 You may not like the shape of the government’s response and I think there’s certainly an argument to be made that there were better solutions, but in a crisis of financial confidence the worst thing you can do is dither. And that’s exactly what European governments have been doing.
If you think of the Greek and post-Greek crises as political rather than financial, I think you’ll have a realistic definition of the extent of the problem. The crisis could still tear the European Union apart—and that would take a huge bite out of the global economic recovery—but it wouldn’t lead to a replay of the post-Lehman crisis that almost took down the financial markets of the entire developed world.
The crisis could set back growth in Europe for years and that would lead to lower overall global growth but it’s hard for me to see the financial ripples turning into a tidal wave anywhere outside of Europe.
This is a truly nasty crisis. But the post-Lehman crisis threatened the end of the financial world as the developed economies of the globe know it. This one doesn’t.
For me, Spain is the real concern. If what’s happening in Greece replays itself in Spain, watch out!
Funny you should mention that Greece cannot comply with EU requirements. The good old USA would not meet those requirements either.
All above comments:
Well said! Greece never was qualified to be in EU It literately “squeezed” in by (my guess) little cheating. As the Germans put it, the “lazy Greek” took easy path. They should be thrown out of EU. The only good thing I see in Greece is its tourism.
Greece has tourism and feta.
For me, they will leave the Euro zone, as I cannot see how they can comply with the EU and IMF requirements and survive.
Right now I’m holding a modest position in EUO (ETF that’s double short the Euro), and thinking about increasing it somewhat. Anyone have other thoughts on how to make lemonade from this? Most Greek companies of any significance are ship owners. It seems to me their business is tied more closely to world economy, not so much to Greece itself. I don’t see shorting these companies as a very direct play on the downfall of Greece when it occurs. I see Greece as primarily a domestic political problem. I don’t see them able to get their government workers to ever voluntarily take the cuts that are necessary. It’s going to have to collapse catastrophically rather than be dismantled in an orderly manner.
I don’t see the US problem as analogous. The US still makes a lot of things that the world wants. All Greece has to sell is olives, and various nasty tasting wines and liquors. They haven’t any exportable natural resources of consequence — the place is just screwed so far as I can see.
cautious investor
My take is that it is painful for people to reduce their standard of living. Riots in Greece show this. How easy will it be for a pampered America to downsize their pleasures? The health care fight shows this. Divided Government shows this.
I think the collapse of America is almost certain. Look at what happened to Argentina and the USSR. America will need to be forced to downsize before they will do it. A collapse of the currency would do it. When America is out of money and credit they will downsize. I doubt if we as a people have the gumption to do it before then.
I agree that while possible, Greece taking down the world financial system may not be probable. I wonder how you and readers here would estimate the probability of the U.S. making another serious dent in the world financial markets in a couple of years possibly much bigger than the current one. Public debt is rising at an alarming rate and with tax receipts dwindling and unemployment likely to be high for some time funds to pay for this are going to be hard to come by. I don’t want to sound like a perma bear. I would actually like to hear a convincing argument as to why I shouldn’t be worried about this problem because I believe that it could take down world financial markets. Greece might just be a model of what’s to come?
Greece today seems very much like Argentina of 2001 before the largest sovereign default in history (so far)…. minus a few differences of course, but many similarities. Both countries still think themselves as Western European nations, in culture, language, and ethnicity…. yes, but not in economics. Having travelled to Argentina last year, I noticed that Argentina today is economically more like Mexico and Peru rather than the “Paris of South America”, and Greece probably approaching it. Unlike China, the governments of those countries took the shortcut to “prosperity” by inflating their currencies and tried to borrow their way to the same economic level as Germany and France, and they don’t want to turn their nations into minimum wage style sweatshops for Walmart and Target to earn the hard cash required for growth. They should learn from the Asians. China’s currency policy and national development strategy is quite the opposite.